I bought my first pack of balms in 2021, back when the balm was only peppermint. I was obsessed and finished the pack right around christmas this year. Unfortunately, when I purchased my second batch, the formula had both peppermint and rosemary, which seems to give the balm a very thin and gritty feel instead of the thick and smooth balm I loved. The new batch isn’t terrible, it’s just not as great as it used to be. PLEASE BRING THE OLD VERSION BACK!